- 4 -
Q &
ety? The important foundation is to build
social capital which is the glue that holds
society together and which is, fundamen-
tally, an ethical challenge. It’s very hard to
get society to cohere unless there is trust
and building trust is about respecting each
others values and personal dignity. Also,
in terms of “good governance”, the moral
dimension includes bringing some defi ni-
tion by those most affected to the word
“good” and being open to a refocusing; for
example balancing efforts to stop the wide-
spread growth of corruption in government
with some active recognition of the many
resources for integrity that exists within ev-
ery government. There are always certain
individuals who are exemplars of integrity
and they exist at every level of the commu-
nity – but they are seldom recognized and
held up for emulation. And there are also,
strong cultural traditions that exists that
support ethical behavior.
How will Creative’s Civil Society and Gov-
ernance Team respond to development
needs?
My goal would be to create a distinctive
approach to the challenges of society and
governance and civil society strengthening
that is characterized by proven and practi-
cal measures coupled with a sophisticated
approach toward the ethical content in
development. The unique tools of develop-
ment ethics will assist in that endeavor.
What is the role of development ethics,
how does it help foster positive change?
The primary role of development ethics
is to facilitate, to raise challenging moral
issues, and to guide analysis of moral
concerns. That involves creating an envi-
ronment that is conducive to what is called
deliberative participation – this is when
people commit to a dialogue that is toler-
ant of opposing views, respectful of the
personhood of all participants and willing
to listen to seek common ground. Develop-
ment ethicists also help people to identify
both universal and particular values that
come out of peoples’ own life experiences
and aspirations and to put development
language to these expressions and aspira-
tions. Finally, development ethicists help
citizens to articulate their expectations of
ethical performance in ways that they can
hold governments accountable for ethical
results.
In 2005, you wrote a paper, The Relevance
of Development Ethics for USAID, co-au-
thored with Dr. David Crocker. What is the
state of development ethics in democracy
and governance?
That paper was specifi cally looking at
Democracy and Governance assessments
and suggesting that there is a role for
including normative questions, questions
of values and assessing how well govern-
ments serve their people. At present, many
ethical questions are not asked in such
assessments for example, regarding the
responsiveness of leaders to the aspira-
tions of their people and the track record
of performance of such leaders compared
to the ideals that they expressed. For
example, a recent USAID study on the
character of democracy was completely
staffed by economists and questions of
what constitutes “good” governance, and
who decides what good governance is,
and what role should human rights play in
evaluating governance – were not consid-
ered.
And, also, when values confl ict based
on cultural traditions, for instance, when
women are held as second placed citizens
– how is USAID supposed to handle that.
How do we respect our own values but
also to take due recognition of cultural
traditions of that society? For Americans
going into a foreign country, they must take
ownership of their own values and say:
“here is where I am coming from —let’s
have a discussion.” One way to address
this is sometimes to put the challenge
back on them and say: “In my society we
think women have an equal role to play,
tell me why women should not have an
equal role in your society.”
AFGHANISTAN: CHILD-CENTERED TEACHING
HELPS STUDENTS LEARN IN NEW WAYS
asia
A
t the Charmghar Khana Boys’ School
in Shiberghan, a mid-sized town in
northern Afghanistan, children are
learning about chemistry in a very differ-
ent way than they were a year ago.
During a recent visit, Ms. Roya Qader’s
students were modeling molecular
structures by holding hands and moving
about the room to show how chemical
compounds formed and interacted with
each other. In contrast to most Afghan
classrooms, where memorization and rep-
etition are the norm, Roya’s class was full
of energy, with children participating—and
learning—in a dynamic and supportive
environment.
Roya, who has been a teacher for only
three years, recently completed teacher
methodology training offered to all
Charmghar Khana teachers through the
Building Education Support Systems for
Teachers (BESST) project.
BESST is implemented by Creative Associ-
ates International, Inc. and made pos-
sible by the U.S. Agency for International
Development. A fi ve-year project, BESST is
helping to rebuild Afghanistan’s tattered
education infrastructure by establishing
standards and systems for assessing
teacher qualifi cations. Its teacher training
component seeks to inculcate a modern
child-centered interactive methodology
into Afghanistan’s classrooms.
Since many Afghan teachers have had
limited training and educational creden-
tials, BESST’s teacher capacity building
includes the establishment of support
systems such as peer learning groups and
teacher resource centers. These support
systems have been incorporated to ensure
AFGHAN STUDENTS LIKE THESE BOYS ARE LEARN-
ING BETTER THANKS TO INTERACTIVE LEARN-
ING AND CHILD-CENTERED APPROACHES MADE
AVAILABLE TO TEACHERS THROUGH THE BESST
PROGRAM.
PHOTO BY: BESST PARTNER SAVE THE CHILDREN USA
>> CONTINUES FROM PAGE 3
CONTINUES ON PAGE 5>>